On November 6, 2025, the U.S. Interior Department added copper, silver and lead to its final critical minerals list, among 10 new entries. All three are main metals of a polymetallic deposit, where the USGS vein model places them in zones around a single intrusion.

Silver shows how closely these metals are linked. The USGS says U.S. silver is “primarily obtained as a byproduct from lead-zinc, copper, and gold mines”, and six other metals on the infographic are also recovered as by-products.

‍

Copper and Gold Form Closest to the Heat

The U.S. Geological Survey describes the order in which metals settle in a polymetallic vein deposit: copper and gold closest to the heat source, then zinc, lead and silver, with manganese at the outer edge. That is the order the infographic follows, read from the bottom up.

Not every deposit forms in the same kind of rock. In vein deposits, the metals fill faults and fractures around the intrusion. In replacement deposits, they take the place of limestone or dolomite, and the USGS model for these shows the same order with one difference: zinc moves out to the edge with manganese instead of sitting in the middle.

‍

In Tin Deposits, Gold Moves to the Edge

A third USGS model covers tin-polymetallic veins: “multistage Cu-Zn-Sn-Ag-bearing veins” associated with felsic ignimbrites and subvolcanic intrusions. Its sequence runs from tin and tungsten at the centre, through copper, zinc and lead, to gold and silver at the periphery, “or from depths to shallow levels”.

That puts gold at the opposite end from the vein model, where it sits with copper at the core. The infographic follows the general model and marks tin and tungsten as tin-type metals. Eloro Resources, the sponsor of this article, describes epithermal, polymetallic and tin-dominant domains at Iska Iska in Bolivia’s tin belt, with the tin zone sitting atop the polymetallic zone.

‍

Three Host Metals Carry Six By-Products

Zinc carries three of the six by-products in the graphic: indium, cadmium and germanium. Copper carries molybdenum and tellurium, and lead carries bismuth. For indium, the USGS notes that “most zinc producers were not equipped with indium-processing circuits”.

Several of these by-products are now under export controls. China’s February 4, 2025 decision put export controls on items related to tellurium, bismuth, molybdenum and indium, alongside tungsten from the tin-type core, and germanium exports still require licences. The effect on indium phosphide was covered in our August indium article.

‍

The Host Metals Feed Separate Markets

‍

‍

The metals of one deposit end up in markets that have little in common, as the chart above shows using USGS end-use data. Lead is the only one of the five where a single use takes more than half of demand, while silver is split between industrial uses and investment in bars and coins.

The chart’s lead share covers U.S. apparent consumption only, while our lead article cited a global battery share above 85%. Zinc is missing because the USGS gives only the order of its uses: galvanized steel first, then brass and bronze.

‍